Description: Environmental groups' challenge to San Diego County's Climate Action Plan.
-
Golden Door Properties, LLC v. County of San Diego
Case Documents:
Filing Date Type File Action Taken Summary 06/12/2020 Opinion Download Trial court judgment affirmed in part and reversed in part. California Appellate Court Rejected San Diego County’s Plan to Mitigate Greenhouse Gas Impacts with Off-Site Offsets. The California Court of Appeal rejected key aspects of San Diego County’s appeal of a trial court decision that set aside the County’s approvals of a 2018 Climate Action Plan, Guidelines for Determining Significance of Climate Change, and a supplemental environmental impact report (SEIR). The appellate court held that a mitigation measure in the SEIR that permitted the purchase of carbon offsets from projects outside the County, including international projects, violated the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) because the mitigation measure did not require that offsets meet AB 32 requirements, that greenhouse gas emission reductions be additional, and that the offsets originating outside California have greenhouse emissions programs equivalent to or stricter than California’s program. In addition, the appellate court found that the mitigation measure violated CEQA because 100% of greenhouse gas emissions could be offset by projects originating outside California and there were no objective criteria for County officials to use to determine whether a particular offset program was appropriate. The court also found other shortcomings in the SEIR: inadequate cumulative impacts analysis due to the exclusion of greenhouse gas impacts from certain in-process projects; failure to support a finding that the offset mitigation measure was consistent with the Regional Transportation Plan required by SB 375; failure to analyze a smart-growth alternative; and inconsistency between the Climate Action Plan and the SEIR. -
Sierra Club v. County of San Diego
Case Documents:
Filing Date Type File Action Taken Summary 08/31/2018 Tentative Ruling Tentative ruling issued denying the County's motion challenging the adequacy of the administrative record. 03/20/2018 Petition for Writ of Mandate Download Petition for writ of mandate filed. Environmental Groups Challenged New San Diego County Climate Action Plan. Sierra Club and other organizations commenced challenges to a revised Climate Action Plan adopted by San Diego County in 2018. In one case, Sierra Club filed a third amended petition asserting that the County had failed to comply with earlier judicial directives requiring, among other things, that the Climate Action Plan contain enforceable measures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Sierra Club and six other groups also filed this new lawsuit seeking to set aside certain portions of the revised Climate Action Plan and the supplemental environmental impact report on which it was based, and also to set aside a threshold of significance established by the County that the petitioners alleged would allow development not contemplated by a 2011 General Plan Update, so long as developers obtained offsets, which could be obtained out of state or even outside of the country. In the new lawsuit, the petitioners asserted that this “offshoring of GHG emissions offsets” had been done without proper review under the California Environmental Quality Act. -
Golden Door Properties, LLC v. County of San Diego
Case Documents:
Filing Date Type File Action Taken Summary 08/31/2018 Opposition Download Opposition to application for stay and motion for preliminary injunction filed by respondent County of San Diego. 08/22/2018 Application Download Application for stay or, in the alternative, motion for preliminary injunction filed by petitioner-plaintiff Golden Door Properties, LLC.