Koch Industries, Inc. v. John Does 1-25

Filing Date: 2010
Case Categories:
Principal Laws:
Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act, Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, State Law—Trademark Infringement, Lanham Act, Contract Law, State Law—Common Law, State Law—Unfair Competition
Description: Company lawsuit against anonymous bloggers for posting fake press release concerning climate change.
  • Koch Industries, Inc. v. John Does 1-25
    Docket number(s): 2:10-cv-1275-DAK
    Court/Admin Entity: D. Utah
    Case Documents:
    Filing Date Type File Action Taken Summary
    05/09/2011 Memorandum Decision Download Memorandum decision and order issued granting defendants' motion to quash subpoenas, issue protective order, and dismiss complaint. A federal court in Utah dismissed the lawsuit. In its decision, the court held that the company could not disclose the identities of any of the members of the organization, Youth for Climate Truth, that had put out the fake news release. In addition, the court held that the company’s trademarks had not been violated because there was no commercial competition between it and Youth for Climate Truth. It also dismissed the company’s claim that the copying of its website violated anti-computer hacking laws and the terms of use it posted.
    12/28/2010 Complaint Download Complaint filed. Koch Industries filed a lawsuit seeking to punish anonymous pranksters who claimed in a fake press release posted on the internet that it was discontinuing funding to climate denial groups. The lawsuit alleged that defendants issued the fake press release and set up a fake website with the intent to deceive and confuse the public and to disrupt and harm Koch Industries’ business and reputation, and that as a result the company’s business and reputation were harmed.